A label is a claim, not a result
Why identity, purity, and content are three different questions — and why a label answers none of them.
Why identity, purity, and content are three different questions — and why a label answers none of them.

A label tells you what is supposed to be in a vial. It does not tell you what is actually in it. That single sentence is the reason a certificate of analysis exists, and it is worth unpacking because the three questions a COA answers are easy to confuse.
Identity asks: is this the molecule the label names? Purity asks: of everything in the vial, how much is that molecule versus everything else? Content asks: how many milligrams of that molecule are actually here? These are independent. A product can pass identity and fail purity. It can pass purity and fail content. It can pass all three and still fail a safety test like endotoxin. Treating them as one question — "is it good?" — is exactly the mistake a label invites.
The evidence that this is not theoretical is direct. In a 2017 JAMA study of products sold online as SARMs, only about half contained a SARM at all; many held a different unapproved drug, and some held no detectable active compound. That is an identity failure hiding behind a label. In a 2024 study of online semaglutide, the molecule was present (identity passed) but purity was only about 7 to 14% against 99% advertised, the vials held more than labeled (content failed), and one sample carried endotoxin (safety failed) — all in the same products. And the WHO's estimate that at least 1 in 10 medicines in low- and middle-income countries is substandard or falsified describes a market in which labels are wrong by accident or by design, and the buyer cannot tell which from the label.
The thread connecting these is that a label is a claim made by the seller about the seller's own product. A result is a measurement made by someone else on the actual sample. The two have nothing in common except the molecule they describe. A COA is valuable precisely because it is the second and not the first.
So when you read a certificate, look for three separate lines: an identity determination (commonly a mass), a purity figure (commonly a main-peak percent), and a net content figure (milligrams). Each should name its method and its specification. If any one is missing, the certificate is answering only part of the question — and the part it skips is usually the part that fails.
Cites: Van Wagoner et al. JAMA 2017; Ashraf et al. JAMA Network Open 2024; WHO fact sheet 2024.