ExplainerReading a COA2024

A label is a claim, not a result

Why identity, purity, and content are three different questions — and why a label answers none of them.

A label is a claim, not a result
Key findings
  • Identity, purity, and content are three independent questions
  • A label answers none of them — it is a claim by the seller about the seller's own product
  • The 2017 SARMs study, the 2024 semaglutide study, and the WHO estimate all show label-vs-reality gaps
  • A COA is a measurement on the actual sample, which is why it is worth more than a label

A label tells you what is supposed to be in a vial. It does not tell you what is actually in it. That single sentence is the reason a certificate of analysis exists, and it is worth unpacking because the three questions a COA answers are easy to confuse.

Identity asks: is this the molecule the label names? Purity asks: of everything in the vial, how much is that molecule versus everything else? Content asks: how many milligrams of that molecule are actually here? These are independent. A product can pass identity and fail purity. It can pass purity and fail content. It can pass all three and still fail a safety test like endotoxin. Treating them as one question — "is it good?" — is exactly the mistake a label invites.

The evidence that this is not theoretical is direct. In a 2017 JAMA study of products sold online as SARMs, only about half contained a SARM at all; many held a different unapproved drug, and some held no detectable active compound. That is an identity failure hiding behind a label. In a 2024 study of online semaglutide, the molecule was present (identity passed) but purity was only about 7 to 14% against 99% advertised, the vials held more than labeled (content failed), and one sample carried endotoxin (safety failed) — all in the same products. And the WHO's estimate that at least 1 in 10 medicines in low- and middle-income countries is substandard or falsified describes a market in which labels are wrong by accident or by design, and the buyer cannot tell which from the label.

The thread connecting these is that a label is a claim made by the seller about the seller's own product. A result is a measurement made by someone else on the actual sample. The two have nothing in common except the molecule they describe. A COA is valuable precisely because it is the second and not the first.

So when you read a certificate, look for three separate lines: an identity determination (commonly a mass), a purity figure (commonly a main-peak percent), and a net content figure (milligrams). Each should name its method and its specification. If any one is missing, the certificate is answering only part of the question — and the part it skips is usually the part that fails.

Cites: Van Wagoner et al. JAMA 2017; Ashraf et al. JAMA Network Open 2024; WHO fact sheet 2024.

Educational information only. Not medical advice. USA Prime Labs tests research materials for research use only; nothing here is intended for human or veterinary use. Talk to a licensed health care provider about any medical decision.
Related articles
USA Prime Labs
USAPRIME LABS
We test the research before you do

We test the research before you do. Identity, purity, content, endotoxin, metals, sterility — verified on one certificate you can check by QR.

All testing is performed on research materials for research use only. Not for human consumption. Results describe the sample as received and do not constitute medical, clinical, or safety advice.

© 2026 USA Prime Labs. Research use only — not for human consumption.Part of the USA Prime family.